Understanding Income

In the previous chapter, we defined wealth as a stock—a reservoir of value at a given moment. We explored its components: tangible and financial assets, less any liabilities. Now, we turn our attention to the river that fills, and sometimes empties, that reservoir: income.

We experience income in our daily lives—a weekly wage, a monthly salary, a dividend payment, or even a gift from a relative. But what is it, really? Where does it come from, and what are its different forms? This chapter will dissect the concept of income, moving from the familiar to the fundamental, and address some of the enduring philosophical questions it raises.

2.1 What is Income?

At its simplest, income is a flow of value received over a period of time. It is the reward for providing something of value to others. Unlike wealth, which is a snapshot, income can only be measured with a time dimension: euros per hour, dollars per year.

In the most basic economic sense, income is the return on the three factors of production we identified earlier:

• Labor generates wages and salaries.
• Capital generates interest, dividends, and rent.
• Land generates rent.

But one form of income stands apart, both for its importance in a market economy and for the controversies that have always surrounded it: profit.

2.2 Profit

Profit is the residual income that accrues to the owners of a business after all other costs have been paid. If a company sells €1 million worth of goods, but spends €600,000 on raw materials, €200,000 on wages, and €50,000 on interest payments to its bank, its profit is €150,000.

Profit is not merely a random surplus. In a well-functioning market economy, it serves several critical functions:

• A Signal for Resource Allocation: High profits in a particular industry signal to entrepreneurs and investors that society wants more of what that industry is producing. Capital and labor will then flow toward that industry, guided by the beacon of profit. Conversely, losses signal that resources are being wasted and should be moved elsewhere.
• A Reward for Innovation and Risk: When an entrepreneur develops a new product, a more efficient process, or a novel business model, they are taking a risk. There is no guarantee of success. Profit is the potential reward for that risk-taking and innovation. It is the fuel that motivates economic progress.
• A Source of Investment: Profits that are not distributed to owners (retained earnings) are a primary source of funds for business investment. A company uses its profits to build new factories, research new technologies, and hire more people, creating future wealth.

2.3 Is Profit a Theft?

This question has haunted economic thought for centuries. The accusation is simple: if all value is created by labor, then profit is merely the surplus value that the capitalist steals from the worker. The owner pays the worker a wage that is less than the value the worker creates, and pockets the difference.

This argument, most powerfully articulated by Karl Marx, rests on the labor theory of value, which holds that the value of a good is determined solely by the amount of labor required to produce it. If this theory is accepted, then profit does indeed look like an exploitation.

However, most modern economics rejects the labor theory of value in favor of the subjective theory of value. This theory argues that value is not an intrinsic property of a good, but is determined by the subjective preferences of individuals. A bottle of water has little value to someone at a kitchen sink, but immense value to someone dying of thirst in a desert.

From this perspective, profit is not theft. It is the reward for several distinct contributions:

1. Coordinating Production: The entrepreneur (the capitalist) organizes the factors of production—land, labor, and capital—into a coherent whole. This organizational work is a vital function that creates value.
2. Bearing Uncertainty: The entrepreneur advances payment for wages and materials before the product is sold. There is no guarantee that customers will actually buy it. The worker is paid for their time, regardless of the business's success. The entrepreneur bears the risk of loss. Profit is the reward for successfully bearing that uncertainty.
3. Satisfying Consumer Wants: Ultimately, profit is only earned if a business successfully provides goods and services that consumers want, at a price they are willing to pay. Profit is thus a sign that a business has served the community well. A business that produces things no one wants will make losses, not profits.

While abuses certainly occur—through monopoly power, deception, or exploitation—the existence of profit in a competitive market is not, in itself, evidence of theft. It is more accurately seen as the economy's way of measuring and rewarding the creation of value that others are freely willing to pay for.

2.4 Creating Wealth Without Work

If profit is one form of non-wage income, are there others? Can wealth be created without any labor at all? This question takes us to the heart of what we mean by "work" and "creation."

At first glance, the answer seems to be yes. Consider these examples:

• Passive Income: An individual owns shares in a company and receives dividends. They are not working in the traditional sense, yet their wealth increases.
• Capital Gains: Someone buys a painting by an unknown artist for a small sum. Decades later, the artist is famous, and the painting sells for a fortune. The owner did no work to improve the painting; its value increased due to changing tastes and the artist's subsequent efforts.
• Inheritance: A person receives a large sum of money from a relative. They have done absolutely nothing to "earn" it.

Have these individuals created new wealth? In a physical sense, no. The painting is the same painting. The shares represent the same claim on a company. The inherited money is simply transferred from one person to another.

However, in a market sense, new value has been created. The increase in the painting's price reflects a new, widespread subjective valuation. The dividend is the shareholder's share of the profit the company earned by successfully serving its customers. The shareholder provided the capital that made the company's activities possible, and the dividend is the return on that provision. While they did not "work" in the sense of hammering nails or serving customers, they performed the essential function of supplying capital, which is a factor of production.

This leads to a crucial distinction. The creation of market wealth (an increase in monetary value) can occur without any direct labor from the beneficiary. But the creation of real wealth—the actual goods and services that people value—almost always requires human effort, ingenuity, and organization. The shareholder's dividend is not real wealth itself; it is a claim on the real wealth that the company produces. The value of the painting is not real wealth in the sense of bread or medicine; it is a reflection of collective aesthetic judgment.

So, while an individual can certainly see their income and net worth increase without lifting a finger, this is almost always parasitic on the real wealth created by others—the labor of the company's employees, the artistic genius of the painter, or the lifetime of work of the relative who left the inheritance. The only true, primary source of new real wealth is human creativity and effort applied to the natural world.

Go to ➡ Next Page | ➡ Main Page 

   Understanding Income /E-cyclopedia Resources by Kateule Sydney is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0